In “Cabaret,” Tomorrow Belongs to the Silver Center

By Lena Donovan

Published November 15, 2026

I was very moved by Plymouth State University’s performance of “Cabaret” and believe everyone reading this should go. I don’t know if describing Act 2 in detail is an injustice to the reader. I don’t know how to fully put Act 2 into words, and it would be unfair to the cast, crew, and audience to describe something that really needs to be experienced. In the show, we see characters forced to choose between comfort and the ones they love. “What Would You Do?” performed by Alissa Cutting (Fräulein Schneider) reflects the harsh truth of people choosing to ignore the dangers of authoritarianism. The song asks the audience “what would you do” in this situation. 

At the beginning of Act 1, the club is inviting and warm. The dazzling number “Willkommen” sets the tone. Before a word is spoken, the peppy beat the “beautiful” orchestra plays welcomes you to the Kit Kat Klub.

The first shock of the night was looking up at the sign, which shows the nature of the venue’s consciously placed alliteration (notably, some prominent productions have opted to call it the “Kit Kat Club”). Quietly, this is the beginning of the end. Then the wonderful cast comes out in their risque costumes. We’re met with an unique theatrical ensemble, who not only contrast the main protagonist, Cliff Bradshaw (James Kelleher), but pull you deeper into the story. Each costume is drastically different. If it’s not the sparkle of Frenchie’s (Emily Buinicky) eyelashes, it’s the cheeky placement of Texas’s (Riley Scanlon) star embroidery.  

To reinforce this idea, Bradshaw joins the audience himself. By the end of Act 2, we realize that no matter how hard we try to forget our worries, we ultimately can’t. Soon, we find that the Emcee (Jack Downey) tricked us. The Kit Kat Klub is not a place to forget our worries, but to pretend they don’t exist until it’s too late. 

No matter how many times this story is told, it’s still frightening and fresh. The remarkable Sally Bowles (Abby Carlson) pushes this narrative of escapism. An English girl who came to Berlin to pursue her desire for fame, or attention, Bowles’s first few songs are about her freedom, and everything being “perfectly marvelous.” The last scene of Act 1 celebrates the engagement of a new couple, and the start of the new year, 1931. As the scene goes on, the energy moves from excitement to fear. Fritizie/Fraulien Kost (Zoe Nagle) and Ernst Ludwig (Connor Lavertu) dramatically take control of the scene and change the show’s dynamic. The party doesn’t stop, but it turns red. From behind the crowd, Bradshaw and Bowles watch what Germany is becoming in terror.

The entire theatre floods with red light and the audience freezes. Hearts pound and hands sweat. We all know what’s to come, yet none of us want to admit it due to our own fear of reality. We’re met with an intense traditional visual effect, cleverly orchestrated by the technical team and intelligently left to linger through the intermission. 

We see characters having to choose between convenience and the ones they love. I felt trapped in my seat, like I was being watched by the Emcee. The twisted scenes made my body ache for peace. From the center of the audience, I felt a complete shift in energy, first from the Emcee and then in the audience. He changed from a warm and welcoming host to a hostile one. Like the Kit Kat Klub, the Emcee represents the rise of Nazism in Germany.

The audience’s silence was deafening when we saw the carefree characters turn sinister and terrified. The Kit Kat Klub sign loomed over us, with the shininess of the stage lights almost distracting me from the hard truth. It was easy to look at the pretty backdrop, but it wasn’t easy to see characters make their choices. As you judge characters for the choices they make to protect themselves, the experience forces you to ponder your morality. What would you do in their position?

The Emcee describes the club as a queer and free place of love. Everyone is welcome. This is a place to forget your worries and have the best night of your life, every night. The societal norms and unwritten laws disappear. Berlin is almost a refuge from the patriarchal heteronormative standards of the 1930s. Bobby (Taran Engelward) meets Bradshaw, and they seem to have an untouched and unfinished history. Bradshaw is more than uncomfortable not only in Bobby’s presence, but upon hearing his name. Bradshaw came to Berlin for inspiration, not knowing he was entering a growing thornbush. 

The ensemble shares the stage with equal talent and presence. While they all play important and individual roles, there is a standout: Fritizie/Fraulien Kost (Zoe Nagle), who moves the story in unexpected ways. Nagle sings “Married” to the newly engaged Faulien Schnieder (Alissa Cutting) and Herr Schultz (Noah Alers-Alers). Nagle’s performance is jaw-dropping. She delivers the outstanding number entirely in German, reminding us of Sally’s line: “It’s more fun not knowing.” 

Schnieder is German. Schultz is also German, but isn’t seen as anything other than Jewish. Time and time again, characters believe that Germany may be going through a hard time, but it’s not worth it to leave because, as Bowles says, “It’s only politics, and what’s that got to do with us?” Fraulein has built a life for herself in Germany around the principle of keeping to herself. With her old age and traditional values, she feels like doesn’t have the freedom to take a risk. She stood alone for so long, it’s the only way she knows how to live. The loveable and caring Schultz is burned by this principle on multiple occasions. Alers-Alers’s portrayal of Schultz comes across with a tasteful sense of warmth and comfort. That makes the troubling themes of the show all the harder to watch.

I could not recommend this show enough. The cast and crew truly did such an amazing job. There is only so much I can say without spoiling or ruining the show. If you haven’t seen it yet, there are more shows every night until Nov. 18. The show deals with heavy topics so please be respectful of the audience, performers, and your own mental health. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *